Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Pedro Alves - PA Analytics's avatar

The 1,050 attributed versus 600 actual is the exact failure mode, and the Christmas tree framing is the right one: brands try to solve at the wrong level. The part I would add is that the star metric only works if the definition of "new customer" is the same in every platform and in your own store. A big chunk of the double-counting is not the model, it is that each platform's default window counts a returning buyer as new. Fix the definition and the blended number stops contradicting itself. Reading new-customer revenue and spend by channel against one agreed definition, without exporting anything, is what nomu does off a Meta or Google Ads account.

Pedro Alves - PA Analytics's avatar

The 1,050 attributed conversions against 600 real orders is the whole attribution problem in one line: every platform grades its own homework and gives itself an A. The trap is reaching for a single impartial model to settle it, because the models that aggregate every signal are still black boxes and still wrong in ways nobody can inspect. What reconciles is triangulation — platform numbers for direction, a holdout or geo test for incrementality, and the backend for truth. Any one of those alone will lie to you confidently.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?